Collective Governors Island

Poor
Traveller Type:
  : Location, restaurant, quality of linens, beds
  : No hot water at all. Nobody acknowledged this complaint. It was cold day we couldnt wash properly and definitely couldnt shower

Wonderful
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple

Wonderful
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : Location, back drop of NYC and the facilities. Staff was accommodating, and pleasant.

Very Good
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : Our tent was wonderfully appointed and the property grounds and views were amazing.
  : The noise level at night was unbearable. We did not sleep. There are party cruise boats that dock right in front of the property until 4am and play music so loudly that can be heard for miles. Some disclosure about this given the price for a one night stay would have been appreciated.

Good
Traveller Type:
  : location is wonderful
  : strong suggest have water and napkin in room

Very Good
Traveller Type: Family with Young Children
  : Employees are fantastic!
  : Restaurant food is way way overpriced!!

Very Good
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : The oysters seemed frozen not fresh

Wonderful
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple

Wonderful
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple

Very Good
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : I loved mostly everything about our stay. The location was great, my surroundings were peaceful quiet and relaxing. It was so pleasantly strange to be so close to the city and have that much peace! The facilities were kept very clean so we were extremely satisfied with that. Initially, we were worried about how the outdoor bathrooms might be...they were great. The Byredo soaps...like a spa experience. I even looked them up online to purchase for my own home. I loved the comfort of our journey tent and the bed was incredible! We had everything we needed right in our little tent and it was so great to experience the sounds of nature (crickets and the water) and having the luxury of being "indoors" while still feeling like you were outside. I slept like a baby.
  : The food at the Three Peaks Lodge was a HUGE disappointment. As beautifully presented as it was it was extremely over-seasoned and so salty our dishes were practically inedible. We were really looking forward to dinner, I even timed my reservation so that we could see the sunset and from the description on the website I thought we were in for a lovely dining experience. Although our server was an absolute doll, we had to send our first entre back (the shrimp fettuccine) because the pasta was extremely salty. My fianc and I use quite a bit of seasoning so we aren't afraid of flavor. Furthermore my mother and brother are chefs so we are foodies with an experienced palette. When I apologized for sending the dish back the server asked me not to apologize for "my taste" and I felt like she was insinuating that it was me that had the problem. I also asked if it could be re-made without so much salt and she told me that this dish was "pre-marinated" and that if I ordered it again it would taste the same., I have never heard of pasta being pre-marinated. We ordered something else and it wasn't bad. The following morning we attempted to dine again at the Three Peaks and had the same problem with our breakfast. We ordered eggs and potatoes with a side salad and toast. EVERYTHING had been seasoned so heavily that again it was almost inedible. The chef really has to cut back on the salt and allow patrons to add more to their liking. Even my toast was generously dusted with salt and pepper. Toast? We were so bummed and although we will be visiting again we most definitely will not be dining at the restaurant again.